Probably Stolen Guide

How do I make the most money from appraisal?

Timeline

Tap a step for the why and the numbers.

1 Day 8: Hold ₵85 in cash and join the Guild when the Board Member offers it

  • The Join choice only shows if you hold the ₵85. If you are short she returns 7 days later, which costs a week of fees.
  • After Skip Intro her first offer comes on day 5 instead.

2 Day 8: Activate the certificate and put it in the Display Case, next to food

  • Press Transfer ALL twice to take her items, right-click the certificate, Activate, then drag it into the case. It fitted only the lower-left spot for us.
  • An empty case brings nobody, so keep real goods in it too.

3 Day 9: Appraise your first customer's hands

  • The first customer is scripted: 2 hands. We got 6 hands that day and about ₵250 in fees.

4 About day 16: 10 Perfects fill Junior. Pay ₵106 the next day to become Appraiser

  • Hold the price in cash the day after the bar fills. Never press Decline for good: it stops your progress for good.

5 About day 25: 15 more Perfects. Pay ₵128 to become Senior, then allow Plasma Cartridges only

  • Untick Hand and Ribwich in the Appraisal Items dialog. Our next two visits brought only Plasma.

6 About day 39: 25 more Perfects. Pay ₵149 for Master, but only if your estimates land within 10%

  • Master pays only Perfect and Excellent. Everything else is refused, and the third refusal ends the visit.

7 Every visit: Aim at 100 to 104% of the true value, and finish the whole customer

  • Perfect is 95 to 105%, and a higher estimate pays a higher fee.
  • Take no phone call and no Network trip mid-visit: our customer left half-way and the rest went unpaid.

At a glance

Phase What you add Fees per visit (₵) After the lost walk-in (₵) Per day, after the walk-in (₵)
1. Junior Guild (₵85), 3 hands 155 136 63
2. Appraiser Promotion (₵106), 3 Ribwiches 238 217 119
Advanced: Senior Promotion (128), 3 Plasma, 104% estimates 383 359 215
Expert: Master Promotion (149), 3 Plasma, 104% estimates 542 513 335

Every figure assumes all Perfect. From day 14 each visit takes the place of one random walk-in customer, worth about ₵19 on day 14 and rising with the day (₵21 at Appraiser, ₵24 at Senior, ₵29 at Master). Before day 14 nothing is lost.

The full how-to (reading each item, every price feature, the slips) is in the appraisal chapter.

Promotions: how many appraisals each takes

Promotion Perfects needed Visits (3 items each) Days, about Price (₵)
Junior to Appraiser 10 4 7 106
Appraiser to Senior 15 5 9 128
Senior to Master 25 9 14 149
Join to Master 50 about 17 about 30 383

An Excellent adds 7 points instead of 10, so a few misses add a visit or two. A walk-out costs 5 points from Appraiser on.

BasicPhase 1: Junior, hands only

Join for ₵85 and appraise hands: no stock to buy, no machine, no power. This is all you need from day 9, and it already pays more than most first-week lines.

₵136profit over a normal day, per visit
₵63Per day (a visit every 2.15 days)
The numbers
One visit: 3 Cybernetic Hands Per visit (₵) Per day (a visit every 2.15 days) (₵)
Bought nothing nothing
Hands appraised (average value 210) 3 1.4
Fee per Perfect hand: 20 + 15% of 210 51.5 51.5
Fees 155 72
Walk-in customer it replaces (day 14) -19 (0 on days 9 to 13) -9
Profit over a normal day 136 63

How the numbers are worked out
  • fee = floor(your estimate x percent / 100) + base fee. At Junior a Perfect pays 15% on a base of ₵20.
  • A hand is worth about ₵210 on average, from the game's spawn tables (200,000 simulated items). A visit brings 2 to 4 items, 3 on average.
  • The daily chance starts at 33% and grows by half each day without a visit (33, 49, 66, 82, 99), so a Junior visit lands every 2.15 days. ₵155 / 2.15 = ₵72.
  • Our days 9 to 14 at Junior paid about ₵85 a day: 15 hands at about ₵35 each.
Does a visit really cost you a customer? Yes, from day 14
  • Each morning the shop gets a number of walk-in slots: 2 at the starting attractiveness of 250. Display case visitors, the appraisal customer among them, are rolled first and each one that comes uses a slot. The slots left over are filled with random walk-ins.
  • So from day 14 an appraisal visit means one random walk-in fewer that day. On days 9 to 13 no random walk-ins come at all, so it costs nothing.
  • A random walk-in is worth about 0.6 x 0.265 x (90 + 2 x the day): 6 walk-ins in 10 are sellers, and reselling a lot clears about 26.5% of its value. That is about ₵19 on day 14, ₵21 on day 20, ₵24 on day 30 and ₵29 on day 45. How the walk-in value is worked out.
  • Keep attractiveness at 200 or more. Below 200 there are no walk-in slots, so no appraisal customer can come either.

BasicPhase 2: Appraiser

Pay ₵106 at the Board Member's next visit: base fee ₵40, Perfect 18%, and Ribwiches. Same work, nearly twice as much a day.

₵217profit over a normal day, per visit
₵119Per day (a visit every 1.83 days)
The numbers
One visit: 3 Ribwiches Per visit (₵) Per day (a visit every 1.83 days) (₵)
Bought nothing nothing
Ribwiches appraised (average value 219) 3 1.6
Fee per Perfect Ribwich: 40 + 18% of 219 79.4 79.4
Fees 238 130
Walk-in customer it replaces (day 20) -21 -11
Profit over a normal day 217 119

Hand or Ribwich?

Hands pay about ₵78 a Perfect item at Appraiser, Ribwiches ₵79. Keep the one you read more reliably and untick the other. About 14% of Ribwiches are fakes worth ₵40, and a Perfect fee on one is ₵47.

AdvancedAdvanced: Senior, Plasma only, estimates at 104%

Promote to Senior (₵128), allow only Plasma Cartridges and quote 104% of the value you add up. The best item, and the top of the Perfect band on every send.

₵359profit over a normal day, per visit
₵215Per day (a visit every 1.67 days)
The numbers
One visit: 3 Plasma Cartridges Per visit (₵) Per day (a visit every 1.67 days) (₵)
Bought nothing nothing
Cartridges appraised (average value 310) 3 1.8
Your estimate: 104% of 310 322 322
Fee per Perfect cartridge: 60 + 21% of 322 127.7 127.7
Fees 383 229
Walk-in customer it replaces (day 30) -24 -14
Profit over a normal day 359 215

Payback: the two promotions cost ₵106 + ₵128 = ₵234. Senior pays ₵145 more a visit than Appraiser, so it repays in two visits.

Why 104%, and when not to
  • Perfect is any estimate from 95 to 105% of the true value, and the fee is a percent of your estimate. Quoting 104 instead of 100 adds about ₵2.6 a cartridge, about ₵8 a visit.
  • Do it only when you are sure of the value. If your sum is 2% high, 104 becomes 106: Excellent, 18% instead of 21. When unsure, quote 100.
Block everything but Plasma

Right-click the certificate in the case, choose Activate and untick Hand and Ribwich.

The Appraisal Items dialog: a tick box for each item type

ExpertExpert: Master, Plasma only

Promote to Master (₵149): base fee ₵100 and 25% on a Perfect. The highest fee per visit in the game, if your estimates are sharp.

₵513profit over a normal day, per visit
₵335Per day (a visit every 1.53 days)
The numbers
One visit: 3 Plasma Cartridges Per visit (₵) Per day (a visit every 1.53 days) (₵)
Bought nothing nothing
Cartridges appraised (average value 310) 3 2.0
Your estimate: 104% of 310 322 322
Fee per Perfect cartridge: 100 + 25% of 322 180.6 180.6
Fees 542 354
Walk-in customer it replaces (day 45) -29 -19
Profit over a normal day 513 335

Payback: the Master promotion (₵149) adds about ₵159 a visit over Senior, so it repays on the first visit.

The catch: Master refuses Good and worse
  • Only Perfect (25%) and Excellent (21%) pay. A Good, Mediocre or Awful estimate is refused, and the third refusal of a visit ends it.
  • If half your first tries land within 10%, Master still pays about ₵503 a visit against Senior's ₵342.

Sources for this page: the game's own data, our own play, our estimates.

Privacy · Unofficial fan guide